This page has been archived for historical purposes. For current content, visit us at

« "I was wrong" | Main | Kansas School Board Agues That Teaching Facts Is Not "Neutral" »

David Brooks is a Playa Hata


Now that the Times have made their editorial section subscription-only, most missed this inane rant last week from David Brooks. In a nutshell, he blamed the chaos in France on rap music. Obviously, Brooks couldn't be more wrong. The true catalyst was, of course, them shoot 'em up video games those darn French teenagers are always playing. If you missed his column, it's a must read, just for its pure stupidity:

Gangsta, in French
After 9/11, everyone knew there was going to be a debate about the future of Islam. We just didn't know the debate would be between Osama bin Laden and Tupac Shakur.

Yet those seem to be the lifestyle alternatives that are really on offer for poor young Muslim men in places like France, Britain and maybe even the world beyond. A few highly alienated and fanatical young men commit themselves to the radical Islam of bin Laden. But most find their self-respect by embracing the poses and worldview of American hip-hop and gangsta rap.

One of the striking things about the scenes from France is how thoroughly the rioters have assimilated hip-hop and rap culture. It's not only that they use the same hand gestures as American rappers, wear the same clothes and necklaces, play the same video games, and sit with the same sorts of car stereos at full blast. It's that they seem to have adopted the same poses of exaggerated manhood, the same attitudes about women, money and the police. They seem to have replicated the same sort of gang culture, the same romantic visions of gunslinging drug dealers.

In a globalized age it's perhaps inevitable that the culture of resistance gets globalized, too. What we are seeing is what Mark Lilla of the University of Chicago calls a universal culture of the wretched of the earth. The images, modes and attitudes of hip-hop and gangsta rap are so powerful they are having a hegemonic effect across the globe.

American ghetto life, at least as portrayed in rap videos, now defines for the young, poor and disaffected what it means to be oppressed. Gangsta resistance is the most compelling model for how to rebel against that oppression. If you want to stand up and fight The Man, the Notorious B.I.G. shows the way.

This is a reminder that for all the talk about American cultural hegemony, American countercultural hegemony has always been more powerful. America's rebellious countercultural heroes exert more influence around the world than the clean establishment images from Disney and McDonald's. This is our final insult to the anti-Americans; we define how to be anti- American, and the foreigners who attack us are reduced to borrowing our own cliches.

When rap first came to France, American rappers dominated the scene, but now the suburban immigrant neighborhoods have produced their own stars in their own language. French rap lyrics today are like the American gangsta lyrics of about five or 10 years ago, when it was more common to fantasize about cop killings and gang rape.

Most of the lyrics can't be reprinted in this newspaper, but you can get a sense of them from, say, a snippet from a song from Bitter Ministry:

"Another woman takes her beating./This time she's called Brigitte./She's the wife of a cop."

Or this from Mr. R's celebrated album "PolitiKment IncorreKt":

"France is a bitch. Don't forget to [deleted] her to exhaustion. You have to treat her like a whore, man! My niggers and my Arabs, our playground is the street with the most guns!"

The French gangsta pose is familiar. It is built around the image of the strong, violent hypermacho male, who loudly asserts his dominance and demands respect. The gangsta is a brave, countercultural criminal. He has nothing but rage for the institutions of society: the state and the schools. He shows his own cruel strength by dominating women. It is perhaps no accident that until the riots, the biggest story coming out of these neighborhoods was the rise of astonishing and horrific gang rapes.

In other words, what we are seeing in France will be familiar to anyone who watched gangsta culture rise in this country. You take a population of young men who are oppressed by racism and who face limited opportunities, and you present them with a culture that encourages them to become exactly the sort of people the bigots think they are -- and you call this proud self- assertion and empowerment. You take men who are already suspected by the police because of their color, and you romanticize and encourage criminality so they will be really despised and mistreated. You tell them to defy oppression by embracing self-destruction.

In America, at least, gangsta rap is sort of a game. The gangsta fan ends up in college or law school. But in France, the barriers to ascent are higher. The prejudice is more impermeable, and the labor markets are more rigid. There really is no escape.

Needless to say, Brooks isn't keepin' shit real. [Thanks for the tip, John]


Judging by the responses posted here and those from the webmaster himself, I'd say Brooks is completely correct. It is amazing that people today are incapable of providing comment or feedback to something without the words: shit, bullshit, fuck, asshole, motherfucker, idiot, dumbass. The true reality of mass hip hop is that it plays to the base urges of all people (if white kids weren't buying it it wouldn't be making half the money the industry generates). The sad reality is that hip hop is a base detestable "art" form that offers little to society as a whole. The everyday langauge I hear from many people that subscribe to that lifestyle is horrfying. Yet, it is easier to brush aside any comment of hip hop as "racist" and say black people are just always kept down. As one strong black man, I got educated, got a job, and developed self respect. I don't blame others for my problems and I've learned how to use a respectable venacular. I want to create a better world, not the one the majority of you are pulling us into.

Mr Brrrrroks, avez-vous déja visité les cités francaises? Je crois que non. Votre article meme que vos avis n'est qu une connerie ....... elo

I can't believe that some prick from USA tries to analyze situation in Europe. Sorry you guys in USA, but you just aren't smart enough to be able to understand to culture that doesn't like hamburgers and coke... Those "Gangstas" in France are just poor kids who have seen to much of MTV and don't want to act a we are used to... Well they got no chance, their next generations will become civilized and they'll start rap about hoes and weed:D

You are stupid.

This article is shit.

"In America, at least, gangsta rap is sort of a game. The gangsta fan ends up in college or law school."

Oops, except conservative ideology is about destroying the kinds of "big government" social safety nets that would actually make this statement true in America.

David Brooks was also part of the crowd back in the early 90's who thought the Beach Boys were too subversive for Pa Bush's innaugural. What a dweeb!

Hey, did somebody smash David's face up in photoshop? You can't tell me he really looks that goofy!

I didn't know they made toupees that simulated male pattern baldness. (yeah, I'm ducking the issue and attacking the person for looking funny. booya)

...and I also heard that the French Revolution was incited by Robespierre when he dropped his multi-platnium classic, "Off wit their headz".

To some degree, he's right. It's just sad that, as a journalist, he never saw the need to investigate what the fuck he was editorializing about any further. He shouldn't even be allowed to pontificate on sub-cultures he has never taken the time to learn about. Sure, some of the negative things he says are true - there's a lot of rap music that's just bloated huffing and puffing that doesn't do any good for anything - except, maybe rocking your car with the beat. But he never talks about the side of rap music that represents black people being disenfranchised(and this typifies his whole Republican philosophy) or how hip-hop culture sorts things out for confused people productively and can be about positivity. But most importantly, he can't comprehend that rap music doesn't create these problems or perpetuate them. He should learn to appreciate the arts as a way for people to get their frustrations on the table, at the least. I think we'd be extra screwed without the catharsis rap music provides. It proves what a stodgy, stereotypical, rich, white- guy, with a stick up his butt he is. If we lived in the negative universe he believes to be reality, rap music might actually be what he's describing here.

Post a comment

Verification (needed to reduce spam): Can't read the above words? Click the circular arrows for a new anti-spam test.

FREEdubya on Twitter FREEdubya on Hype Machine
FREEdubya on Facebook Subscribe to FREEdubya
Williamsburg Waterfront Concerts
Happy Hours and Events

W-Burg Guides


June 2010May 2010April 2010March 2010February 2010January 2010December 2009November 2009October 2009September 2009August 2009July 2009June 2009May 2009April 2009March 2009February 2009January 2009December 2008November 2008October 2008September 2008August 2008July 2008June 2008May 2008April 2008March 2008February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007October 2007September 2007August 2007July 2007June 2007May 2007April 2007March 2007February 2007January 2007December 2006November 2006October 2006September 2006August 2006July 2006June 2006May 2006April 2006March 2006February 2006January 2006December 2005November 2005October 2005September 2005August 2005July 2005June 2005May 2005April 2005March 2005February 2005January 2005December 2004November 2004October 2004September 2004August 2004July 2004June 2004Nov. 1998 - May 2004

Hype Machine Music Widget MP3 Blogs

Our Books

Williamsburg & Brooklyn Links

New York and Williamsburg Apartment Listings


Peeps We Like


mail | at |

Advertise With Us


Founding Editor:
Robert Lanham

Senior Editor:
Brian Ries

Senior Music Editor:
Nicole Wasilewicz

Foreign Correspondent:
Lisa Baldini

Senior Food/Bars Editor:
Fiona Goldstein

Senior Film Editor:
Dave Thomas

Senior Photo Editor:
Clarissa Roudabush

Elizabeth Brady
Janice Chou
Lauren Mooney
Andrew Ritchie
Erica Sackin
Jackie Snow
Colin Steers
Lauren Taylor

About FREEwilliamsburg

Add me to your
mailing list

Powered by
Movable Type 3.2

Advertise on New York blogs


Advertise With